diff options
Diffstat (limited to 'docs/release/results/euphrates_fraser_comparison.rst')
| -rw-r--r-- | docs/release/results/euphrates_fraser_comparison.rst | 602 |
1 files changed, 602 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/docs/release/results/euphrates_fraser_comparison.rst b/docs/release/results/euphrates_fraser_comparison.rst new file mode 100644 index 000000000..53dfb994f --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/release/results/euphrates_fraser_comparison.rst @@ -0,0 +1,602 @@ +.. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International +.. License. +.. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 + +======================================================= +Test results analysis for Euphrates and Fraser releases +======================================================= + +TC002 +----- + +The round-trip-time (RTT) between 2 VMs on different blades is measured using +ping. + +Most test run measurements result on average between 0.39 and 4.00 ms. +Compared with Euphrates release, the average RTT result of the same pod experiences +a slight decline in Fraser release. For example, the average RTT of arm-pod5 is +1.518 in Ehphrates and 1.714 in Fraser. The average RTT of intel-pod18 is 1.6575 +ms in Ehphrates and 1.856 ms in Fraser. + +{ + + "huawei-pod2:stable/euphrates": [0.3925], + + "lf-pod2:stable/euphrates": [0.5315], + + "lf-pod1:stable/euphrates": [0.62], + + "huawei-pod2:stable/fraser": [0.677], + + "lf-pod1:stable/fraser": [0.725], + + "flex-pod2:stable/euphrates": [0.795], + + "huawei-pod12:stable/euphrates": [0.87], + + "ericsson-pod1:stable/fraser": [0.9165], + + "huawei-pod12:stable/fraser": [1.0465], + + "lf-pod2:stable/fraser": [1.2325], + + "intel-pod5:stable/euphrates": [1.25], + + "ericsson-virtual3:stable/euphrates": [1.2655], + + "ericsson-pod1:stable/euphrates": [1.372], + + "zte-pod2:stable/fraser": [1.395], + + "arm-pod5:stable/euphrates": [1.518], + + "huawei-virtual4:stable/euphrates": [1.5355], + + "ericsson-virtual4:stable/fraser": [1.582], + + "huawei-virtual3:stable/euphrates": [1.606], + + "intel-pod18:stable/euphrates": [1.6575], + + "huawei-virtual4:stable/fraser": [1.697], + + "huawei-virtual8:stable/euphrates": [1.709], + + "arm-pod5:stable/fraser": [1.714], + + "huawei-virtual3:stable/fraser": [1.716], + + "intel-pod18:stable/fraser": [1.856], + + "huawei-virtual2:stable/euphrates": [1.872], + + "arm-pod6:stable/euphrates": [1.895], + + "huawei-virtual2:stable/fraser": [1.964], + + "huawei-virtual1:stable/fraser": [1.9765], + + "huawei-virtual9:stable/euphrates": [2.0745], + + "arm-pod6:stable/fraser": [2.209], + + "huawei-virtual1:stable/euphrates": [2.495], + + "ericsson-virtual2:stable/euphrates": [2.7895], + + "ericsson-virtual4:stable/euphrates": [3.768], + + "ericsson-virtual1:stable/euphrates": [3.8035], + + "ericsson-virtual3:stable/fraser": [3.9175], + + "ericsson-virtual2:stable/fraser": [4.004] + +} + +TC010 +----- + +The tool we use to measure memory read latency is lmbench, which is a series of +micro benchmarks intended to measure basic operating system and hardware system +metrics. Compared with Euphrates release, the memory read latency of the same pod +also experience a slight decline. Virtual pods seem to have a higher memory read +latency than physical pods. Compared with X86 pods, the memory read latency of +arm pods is significant higher. + +{ + + "ericsson-pod1:stable/euphrates": [5.7785], + + "flex-pod2:stable/euphrates": [5.908], + + "ericsson-virtual1:stable/euphrates": [6.412], + + "intel-pod18:stable/euphrates": [6.5905], + + "intel-pod5:stable/euphrates": [6.6975], + + "ericsson-pod1:stable/fraser": [7.0645], + + "ericsson-virtual4:stable/euphrates": [7.183], + + "intel-pod18:stable/fraser": [7.4465], + + "zte-pod2:stable/fraser": [8.1865], + + "ericsson-virtual2:stable/euphrates": [8.4985], + + "huawei-pod2:stable/euphrates": [8.877], + + "huawei-pod12:stable/euphrates": [9.091], + + "huawei-pod2:stable/fraser": [9.236], + + "huawei-pod12:stable/fraser": [9.615], + + "ericsson-virtual3:stable/euphrates": [9.719], + + "ericsson-virtual2:stable/fraser": [9.8925], + + "huawei-virtual4:stable/euphrates": [10.1195], + + "huawei-virtual3:stable/euphrates": [10.19], + + "huawei-virtual2:stable/fraser": [10.22], + + "huawei-virtual1:stable/euphrates": [10.3045], + + "huawei-virtual9:stable/euphrates": [10.318], + + "ericsson-virtual4:stable/fraser": [10.5465], + + "ericsson-virtual3:stable/fraser": [10.9355], + + "huawei-virtual3:stable/fraser": [10.95], + + "huawei-virtual2:stable/euphrates": [11.274], + + "huawei-virtual4:stable/fraser": [11.557], + + "lf-pod1:stable/euphrates": [15.7025], + + "lf-pod2:stable/euphrates": [15.8495], + + "lf-pod2:stable/fraser": [16.5595], + + "lf-pod1:stable/fraser": [16.8395], + + "arm-pod5:stable/euphrates": [18.092], + + "arm-pod5:stable/fraser": [18.744], + + "huawei-virtual1:stable/fraser": [19.8235], + + "huawei-virtual8:stable/euphrates": [33.999], + + "arm-pod6:stable/euphrates": [41.5605], + + "arm-pod6:stable/fraser": [55.804] + +} + +TC011 +----- + +Iperf3 is a tool for evaluating the packet delay variation between 2 VMs on +different blades. In general, the packet delay variation of the two releases +look similar. + +{ + + "arm-pod6:stable/fraser": [1], + + "ericsson-pod1:stable/fraser": [1], + + "ericsson-virtual2:stable/fraser": [1], + + "ericsson-virtual3:stable/fraser": [1], + + "lf-pod2:stable/fraser": [1], + + "huawei-virtual1:stable/fraser": [2997], + + "huawei-virtual2:stable/euphrates": [2997], + + "flex-pod2:stable/euphrates": [2997.5], + + "huawei-virtual3:stable/euphrates": [2998], + + "huawei-virtual3:stable/fraser": [2999], + + "huawei-virtual9:stable/euphrates": [3000], + + "huawei-virtual8:stable/euphrates": [3001], + + "huawei-virtual4:stable/euphrates": [3002], + + "huawei-virtual4:stable/fraser": [3002], + + "ericsson-virtual3:stable/euphrates": [3006], + + "huawei-virtual1:stable/euphrates": [3007], + + "ericsson-virtual2:stable/euphrates": [3009], + + "intel-pod18:stable/euphrates": [3010], + + "ericsson-virtual4:stable/euphrates": [3017], + + "lf-pod2:stable/euphrates": [3021], + + "arm-pod5:stable/euphrates": [3022], + + "arm-pod6:stable/euphrates": [3022], + + "ericsson-pod1:stable/euphrates": [3022], + + "huawei-pod12:stable/euphrates": [3022], + + "huawei-pod12:stable/fraser": [3022], + + "huawei-pod2:stable/euphrates": [3022], + + "huawei-pod2:stable/fraser": [3022], + + "intel-pod18:stable/fraser": [3022], + + "intel-pod5:stable/euphrates": [3022], + + "lf-pod1:stable/euphrates": [3022], + + "lf-pod1:stable/fraser": [3022], + + "zte-pod2:stable/fraser": [3022], + + "huawei-virtual2:stable/fraser": [3025] + +} + +TC012 +----- + +Lmbench is also used to measure the memory read and write bandwidth. +Like TC010, compared with Euphrates release, the memory read and write bandwidth +of the same pod also experience a slight decline. And compared with X86 pods, the memory +read and write bandwidth of arm pods is significant lower. + +{ + + "lf-pod1:stable/euphrates": [22912.39], + + "lf-pod2:stable/euphrates": [22637.67], + + "lf-pod1:stable/fraser": [20552.9], + + "flex-pod2:stable/euphrates": [20229.99], + + "lf-pod2:stable/fraser": [20058.925], + + "ericsson-pod1:stable/fraser": [18930.78], + + "intel-pod18:stable/fraser": [18757.545], + + "ericsson-virtual1:stable/euphrates": [17474.965], + + "ericsson-pod1:stable/euphrates": [17127.38], + + "ericsson-virtual4:stable/euphrates": [16219.97], + + "ericsson-virtual2:stable/euphrates": [15652.28], + + "ericsson-virtual3:stable/euphrates": [15551.26], + + "ericsson-virtual4:stable/fraser": [15389.465], + + "ericsson-virtual2:stable/fraser": [15343.79], + + "huawei-pod2:stable/euphrates": [15017.2], + + "huawei-pod2:stable/fraser": [14870.78], + + "huawei-virtual4:stable/euphrates": [14266.34], + + "huawei-virtual1:stable/euphrates": [14233.035], + + "huawei-virtual3:stable/euphrates": [14227.63], + + "zte-pod2:stable/fraser": [14157.99], + + "huawei-pod12:stable/euphrates": [14147.245], + + "huawei-pod12:stable/fraser": [14126.99], + + "intel-pod18:stable/euphrates": [14058.33], + + "huawei-virtual3:stable/fraser": [13929.67], + + "huawei-virtual2:stable/euphrates": [13862.85], + + "huawei-virtual4:stable/fraser": [13847.155], + + "huawei-virtual2:stable/fraser": [13702.92], + + "huawei-virtual1:stable/fraser": [13496.45], + + "intel-pod5:stable/euphrates": [13280.32], + + "ericsson-virtual3:stable/fraser": [12733.19], + + "huawei-virtual9:stable/euphrates": [12559.445], + + "huawei-virtual8:stable/euphrates": [8998.02], + + "arm-pod5:stable/euphrates": [4388.875], + + "arm-pod5:stable/fraser": [4326.11], + + "arm-pod6:stable/euphrates": [4260.2], + + "arm-pod6:stable/fraser": [3809.885] + +} + +TC014 +----- + +The Unixbench is used to evaluate the IaaS processing speed with regards to +score of single CPU running and parallel running. Below are the single CPU running +scores. It can be seen that the processing test results vary from scores 715 to 3737. +In general, the single CPU score of the two releases look similar. + +{ + + "lf-pod2:stable/fraser": [3737.6], + + "lf-pod2:stable/euphrates": [3723.95], + + "lf-pod1:stable/fraser": [3702.7], + + "lf-pod1:stable/euphrates": [3669], + + "intel-pod5:stable/euphrates": [3388.6], + + "intel-pod18:stable/euphrates": [3298.4], + + "flex-pod2:stable/euphrates": [3208.6], + + "ericsson-pod1:stable/fraser": [3131.6], + + "intel-pod18:stable/fraser": [3098.1], + + "ericsson-virtual1:stable/euphrates": [2988.9], + + "zte-pod2:stable/fraser": [2831.4], + + "ericsson-pod1:stable/euphrates": [2669.1], + + "ericsson-virtual4:stable/euphrates": [2598.5], + + "ericsson-virtual2:stable/fraser": [2559.7], + + "ericsson-virtual3:stable/euphrates": [2553.15], + + "huawei-pod2:stable/euphrates": [2531.2], + + "huawei-pod2:stable/fraser": [2528.9], + + "ericsson-virtual4:stable/fraser": [2527.8], + + "ericsson-virtual2:stable/euphrates": [2526.9], + + "huawei-virtual4:stable/euphrates": [2407.4], + + "huawei-virtual3:stable/fraser": [2379.1], + + "huawei-virtual3:stable/euphrates": [2374.6], + + "huawei-virtual4:stable/fraser": [2362.1], + + "huawei-virtual2:stable/euphrates": [2326.4], + + "huawei-virtual9:stable/euphrates": [2324.95], + + "huawei-virtual1:stable/euphrates": [2302.6], + + "huawei-virtual2:stable/fraser": [2299.3], + + "huawei-pod12:stable/euphrates": [2232.2], + + "huawei-pod12:stable/fraser": [2229], + + "huawei-virtual1:stable/fraser": [2171.3], + + "ericsson-virtual3:stable/fraser": [2104.8], + + "huawei-virtual8:stable/euphrates": [2085.3], + + "arm-pod5:stable/fraser": [1764.2], + + "arm-pod5:stable/euphrates": [1754.4], + + "arm-pod6:stable/euphrates": [716.15], + + "arm-pod6:stable/fraser": [715.4] + +} + +TC069 +----- + +With the block size changing from 1 kb to 512 kb, the memory write bandwidth +tends to become larger first and then smaller within every run test. Below are +the scores for 32mb block array. + +{ + + "intel-pod18:stable/euphrates": [18871.79], + + "intel-pod18:stable/fraser": [16939.24], + + "intel-pod5:stable/euphrates": [16055.79], + + "arm-pod6:stable/euphrates": [13327.02], + + "arm-pod6:stable/fraser": [11895.71], + + "flex-pod2:stable/euphrates": [9384.585], + + "zte-pod2:stable/fraser": [9375.33], + + "ericsson-pod1:stable/euphrates": [9331.535], + + "huawei-pod12:stable/euphrates": [9164.88], + + "ericsson-pod1:stable/fraser": [9140.42], + + "huawei-pod2:stable/euphrates": [9026.52], + + "huawei-pod12:stable/fraser": [8993.37], + + "huawei-virtual9:stable/euphrates": [8825.805], + + "huawei-pod2:stable/fraser": [8794.01], + + "huawei-virtual2:stable/fraser": [7670.21], + + "ericsson-virtual1:stable/euphrates": [7615.97], + + "ericsson-virtual4:stable/euphrates": [7539.23], + + "arm-pod5:stable/fraser": [7479.32], + + "arm-pod5:stable/euphrates": [7403.38], + + "huawei-virtual3:stable/euphrates": [7247.89], + + "ericsson-virtual2:stable/fraser": [7219.21], + + "huawei-virtual2:stable/euphrates": [7205.35], + + "huawei-virtual1:stable/euphrates": [7196.405], + + "ericsson-virtual3:stable/euphrates": [7173.72], + + "huawei-virtual4:stable/euphrates": [7131.47], + + "ericsson-virtual2:stable/euphrates": [7129.08], + + "huawei-virtual4:stable/fraser": [7059.045], + + "huawei-virtual3:stable/fraser": [7023.57], + + "lf-pod1:stable/euphrates": [6928.18], + + "lf-pod2:stable/euphrates": [6875.88], + + "lf-pod2:stable/fraser": [6834.7], + + "lf-pod1:stable/fraser": [6775.27], + + "ericsson-virtual4:stable/fraser": [6522.86], + + "ericsson-virtual3:stable/fraser": [5835.59], + + "huawei-virtual8:stable/euphrates": [5729.705], + + "huawei-virtual1:stable/fraser": [5617.12] + +} + +TC082 +----- + +For this test case, we use perf to measure context-switches under load. +High context switch rates are not themselves an issue, but they may point the +way to a more significant problem. + +{ + + "zte-pod2:stable/fraser": [306.5], + + "huawei-pod12:stable/euphrates": [316], + + "lf-pod2:stable/fraser": [337.5], + + "intel-pod18:stable/euphrates": [340], + + "intel-pod18:stable/fraser": [343.5], + + "intel-pod5:stable/euphrates": [357.5], + + "ericsson-pod1:stable/euphrates": [384], + + "lf-pod2:stable/euphrates": [394.5], + + "huawei-pod12:stable/fraser": [399], + + "lf-pod1:stable/euphrates": [435], + + "lf-pod1:stable/fraser": [454], + + "flex-pod2:stable/euphrates": [476], + + "huawei-pod2:stable/euphrates": [518], + + "huawei-pod2:stable/fraser": [544.5], + + "arm-pod5:stable/euphrates": [869.5], + + "huawei-virtual9:stable/euphrates": [1002], + + "huawei-virtual4:stable/fraser": [1138], + + "huawei-virtual4:stable/euphrates": [1174], + + "huawei-virtual3:stable/euphrates": [1239], + + "ericsson-pod1:stable/fraser": [1305], + + "huawei-virtual2:stable/euphrates": [1430], + + "huawei-virtual3:stable/fraser": [1433], + + "huawei-virtual1:stable/fraser": [1470], + + "huawei-virtual1:stable/euphrates": [1489], + + "arm-pod6:stable/fraser": [1738.5], + + "arm-pod6:stable/euphrates": [1883.5] + +} + +TC083 +----- + +TC083 measures network latency and throughput between VMs using netperf. +The test results shown below are for UDP throughout. + +{ + + "lf-pod1:stable/euphrates": [2204.42], + + "lf-pod2:stable/fraser": [1893.39], + + "intel-pod18:stable/euphrates": [1835.55], + + "lf-pod2:stable/euphrates": [1676.705], + + "intel-pod5:stable/euphrates": [1612.555], + + "zte-pod2:stable/fraser": [1543.995], + + "lf-pod1:stable/fraser": [1480.86], + + "intel-pod18:stable/fraser": [1417.015], + + "flex-pod2:stable/euphrates": [1370.23], + + "huawei-pod12:stable/euphrates": [1300.12] + +} |